Exercise works for depression. Almost nobody prescribes it.

Credit: Kampus Production, Pexels

When psychiatrist Dr. Nicholas Fabiano fractured his humerus bone in an arm-wrestling match and briefly stopped exercising, his mental health quickly deteriorated. His regular exercise habit had helped him manage his mental health his entire life, and now, with that option no longer available, he realized that medication and therapy were the most popular tools left for healing. 

Depression is among the most common mental disorders worldwide, frequently co-occurring with obesity, diabetes and heart disease. Yet standard care — medication, therapy or both — leaves 30 to 50% of patients without meaningful improvement and does nothing for the physical burdens. Knowing how effective consistent movement can be in relieving the symptoms of conditions like depression and anxiety, why isn’t exercise regularly prescribed as a treatment? Writing for Big Think, Dr. Fabiano turns that personal experience into a bigger question — why isn’t exercise treated like real medicine? 

The evidence is clear. Hundreds of trials show exercise reduces depressive symptoms, roughly on par with medication or therapy in mild to moderate cases, and is likely additive when used in combination with them. Moreover, for those without the condition, exercising just half the recommended amount for maintaining sound physical health is linked to an 18% lower risk of depression.

That’s because exercise boosts brain neuroplasticity by raising brain-derived neurotrophic factor) levels, sparking new neuron growth, reducing chronic inflammation, promoting a better-regulated stress response and providing the plain psychological lift of self-efficacy, a belief in one’s capacity to achieve one’s goals. Altogether, these shifts make depression harder to develop and less likely to persist.

The thing is, treatment guidelines already name exercise as a first-line option for mild depression, but it just doesn’t make it into the therapy room. A recent survey found that 92% of mental health professionals received no training in how to recommend exercise, and 41% said they never recommend it at all. When it does come up, Fabiano notes, it tends to arrive as “just go work out” — a prescription with no drug, no dose and no duration.

But simply telling patients that exercise works isn’t enough, Fabiano says. Clinicians need training that starts in medical school and continues through residency, along with practical guidance on how to actually prescribe exercise. They also need direct referral pathways to qualified exercise professionals and insurance coverage that makes supervised programs and gym memberships accessible and easy to integrate into care as medication. No further research is needed. What’s left is treating exercise like the medical intervention it already is.

The name “MindSite News” is used with the express permission of Mindsight Institute, an educational organization offering online learning and in-person workshops in the field of mental health and wellbeing. MindSite News and Mindsight Institute are separate, unaffiliated entities that are aligned in making science accessible and promoting mental health globally.

Author

Courtney Wise Randolph is the principal writer for MindSite News Daily. She’s a native Detroiter and freelance writer who was host of COVID Diaries: Stories of Resilience, a 2020 project between WDET and Documenting Detroit which won an Edward R. Murrow Award for Excellence in Innovation. Her work has appeared in Detour Detroit, Planet Detroit, Outlier Media, the Detroit Free Press, Michigan Quarterly Review, and Black in the Middle: An Anthology of the Black Midwest, one of the St. Louis Post Dispatch’s Best Books of 2020. She specializes in multimedia journalism, arts and culture, and authentic community storytelling. Wise Randolph studied English and theatre arts at Howard University and has a BA in arts, sociology and Africana studies at Wayne State University. She can be reached at info@mindsitenews.org.